Search

⏰

Scope

Date
Assign
Status
Not started

To create a portfolio project that analyzes the impact of increasing National Insurance Contributions (NICs) on productivity in the UK, you’ll need to set a well-defined scope and use real-life data sources. Here’s a step-by-step guide to build a comprehensive analysis and showcase it effectively:

Project Scope

Objective: Analyze how changes in employer NICs (rate increase from 13.8% to 15.0% and threshold reduction from £9,100 to £5,000) affect business costs and potentially influence productivity within the UK.

Research Questions:

  1. How does the increase in NICs affect payroll costs across different industries and employee earnings bands?
  2. Can we observe a correlation between NIC costs and productivity across various sectors?
  3. What is the potential impact on employment growth and wage trends following an increase in NICs?

Data Sources:

  • Employee Earnings Data: UK Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings (ASHE) for payroll and earnings distributions.
  • Sectoral Productivity Data: UK Labour Productivity Statistics, detailing productivity by industry sector.
  • Employment and NIC Contributions Data: Labour Market Statistics and social contribution data for industry-based NIC contributions.

Analysis Framework:

  1. Impact on Payroll Costs: Calculate and compare NIC obligations under the old and new rates and thresholds.
  2. Correlation Analysis: Explore the relationship between NIC costs and productivity metrics.
  3. Sector-Wide Impact: Compare the projected NIC impact across different sectors (e.g., finance, healthcare, retail).

Step-by-Step Guide for Analysis

1. Data Collection and Preparation

  • Download ASHE Data:
    • Dataset: Obtain ASHE data on weekly and annual earnings by industry and occupation from the ONS. This will provide employee earnings distributions.
    • Access: ASHE data is available on the ONS website, usually in CSV or Excel format.
  • Labour Productivity Data:
    • Dataset: Download UK Labour Productivity statistics by industry sector. These datasets report output per hour and per worker, offering productivity insights.
    • Access: Available on the ONS website under “Labour productivity by industry.”
  • Social Contributions Data:
    • Dataset: Access NIC contributions data aggregated across sectors. It provides a breakdown of contributions by employer and industry, useful for overall cost projections.
    • Access: Find this in the ONS social contributions or employment cost statistics.

2. NIC Calculation with Current and New Rates

  • Data Processing:
    • Load ASHE earnings data and calculate NIC contributions for each earnings band under the current and new rates.
    • Use thresholds:
      • Current threshold at £9,100 with a 13.8% rate.
      • New threshold at £5,000 with a 15.0% rate.
  • Model Payroll Costs by Industry:
    • Multiply NIC costs by employee counts within each band to get total NICs by industry under both conditions.
    • Summarize the increase in NIC obligations across industries.

3. Correlation Analysis: NIC Costs vs. Productivity

  • Combine NIC and Productivity Data:
    • Aggregate NIC data by industry and join it with productivity data (output per hour and per worker).
    • Calculate the percentage increase in NICs and compare it to productivity changes over recent years.
  • Analyze Correlation:
    • Use correlation analysis (Pearson or Spearman correlation) to check for relationships between NIC costs and productivity indicators.
    • Identify industries where NIC increases may correlate with reduced productivity or slower productivity growth.

4. Sector-Wide Impact and Employment Implications

  • Estimate Industry Burdens:
    • Assess how different industries absorb the additional NIC costs, especially in sectors with low margins (e.g., retail, hospitality).
  • Forecast Employment and Wage Adjustments:
    • Use regression models or time-series analysis to forecast potential employment adjustments or wage changes due to increased NIC costs.
    • For instance, a rise in NICs may lead companies to either freeze wages or reduce hiring, impacting employment trends.

5. Reporting and Visualization

  • Visualize NIC Impacts:
    • Create bar charts showing NIC costs by industry under current and new rates.
    • Display correlation heatmaps or scatter plots to illustrate the relationship between NIC increases and productivity.
  • Present Findings in a Dashboard:
    • Build a dashboard in Power BI or Tableau to allow dynamic exploration of NIC costs, productivity, and employment data.
    • Include interactive elements where viewers can filter by industry or earnings bands.

Example Data Science Tools and Libraries

  • Data Analysis: Use Python with Pandas, Numpy, and Scipy for data cleaning and calculations.
  • Visualization: Matplotlib, Seaborn, or Plotly for data visualization.
  • Statistical Modeling: Statsmodels or Scikit-learn for correlation and regression analysis.
  • Dashboard: Power BI or Tableau for interactive reporting and presentations.

Potential Outcomes and Recommendations

Conclude with recommendations based on findings:

  • For Policy Makers: If NICs negatively impact productivity, consider phased increases or alternative funding mechanisms.
  • For Businesses: Suggest workforce or wage adjustments to absorb additional NIC costs.
  • For Further Research: Highlight areas for additional studies, such as regional NIC impacts or in-depth studies on sectors with the highest productivity drops.